http://blogs.journallive.co.uk/journalblogcentral/

England's search for a World Cup scapegoat protects the real villains

By Mark Douglas on Jul 1, 10 12:57 PM

I got an email the other day, probably the same one that has pinged into your inbox over the last 24 hours. Highly libellous, it was, but salacious enough to pique my interest - not least because it claimed to have the inside track on why England's World Cup bid failed.

The gist of it was a re-heated rumour given an England twist and for about five seconds I could feel the fury building inside me. He did what? With who? And that's the reason why it's going to be 48 years of hurt by the time we rock up in Rio...

Then I thought about it, got my emotions back in check and realised that the original rumour was a load of malicious nonsense with no foundation. I don't know where it originated from, but whoever started the poisonous chain mail is probably sitting back in his bedroom somewhere feeling pretty pleased with himself.

Well he shouldn't be, because creating a scapegoat in an England World Cup year is like shooting fish in a barrel. It's the same every four years - rather than have a reasoned, sensible and intelligent debate about the deep-rooted causes for English doom and gloom when it comes to the biggest show on earth, it's easier to destroy one man's career and move on without solving any of those underlying problems.

In 1998 it was David Beckham. At Euro 2000 it was Phil Neville. In 2002 we got a three-for-one special: David Seaman for his goalkeeping error, Beckham for being too showbiz and Sven for, well, being Swedish and indulging Becks. In 2004 we did alright so they were spared the rod, although Sven copped a bit of flak. In 2006 it was definitely Sven, hounded for two months after stepping down for the crime of accepting the FA's ridiculous contract. And two years ago it was Steve McClaren, ridiculously over-promoted too soon and error-prone but not the sole reason for the problems.

Move on two years and every member of the squad is in scapegoat territory. The Sun ran a picture, surreptitiously obtained from Ledley King's Blackberry, of the players having a beer and, in one player's case, a cigar after the Germany defeat. This was followed inside the 'paper by Ashley Cole privately whining about the English people - again obtained from a private Blackberry account.

Well I'm sorry, but what exactly is wrong with them having a couple of beers after one of the biggest disappointments of their professional careers? Isn't it the British way to drown your sorrows when something terrible or terribly disappointing has happened?

Let's get this straight, England were an embarrassment in South Africa. If France and Italy hadn't conspired to go out in the first round, their performance would have to go down as the worst pound-for-pound display in the tournament. They returned to England humbled: their pretensions of grandeur exposed and their claims to be World Class ground to dust.

Their performances were a travesty and the manager made a series of baffling calls that compounded the obvious lack of energy and belief in the squad. In short, Team England were a monument to how to be less than the sum of your parts.

But do we really think they did it on purpose? Do we really think they don't care that they were removed in the second round of the tournament? And do the 'papers really expect us to swallow that a few beers or a self-indulgent Blackberry message was the reason for their failure?

Yes, the players are paid a ridiculous amount of money to do their day jobs and I'll even accept that some of them should have thought twice about laughing and joking when the disembarked from their plane from Bloemfontein after the Germany defeat. But sticking them in the public stocks? It serves no purpose - not least because most of them will be going through their own private torment right about now.

It probably feels quite cathartic at the moment to hammer the players, the manager and the ridiculous Football Association for this World Cup mess. But isn't it time we grew up and realised that this process of public hand-wringing is part of the problem as well?

This scapegoating releases a bit of tension but it is actually hugely damaging. The targeting of the players and management allows the real culprits to escape pretty much scot free every four years.

Steven Gerrard, John Terry and Frank Lampard will be booed mercilessly by opposition supporters for the first few months of the season but the faceless mandarins who have left our national game in a perilous state will continue in their posts, safe in the knowledge that the players and Capello will take the stick on their behalf.

England were awful in the World Cup but that was a symptom of the problems in our game, not the cause. The people we should really be jeering are the officials at FA and Premier League headquarters who, riddled with self-interest, offered no protection when Liverpool and Manchester United were taken over by American owners who have taken those clubs further away from the fanbase they are meant to serve.

The officials who allowed Wimbledon to be taken over by a franchise in Milton Keynes, and allowed Halifax Town, Chester City and Portsmouth to be driven into extinction or administration while holding up their hands and saying 'It's not our fault'. And the people who have created a division so bloated and reliant on Sky TV money that relegation from it is virtually a death knell for clubs.

This development, more than anything, is responsible for the damaging short-termism that leads to overpaid mercenaries being recruited at the expense of decent young English talent.

Until football fans start trying to take on the authorities who seem determined to undermine both the national team and the national game, there is no hope for England. And no amount of sneering at our World Cup failures will change that.

1 Comments

While I'm uncertain if the author goes into all of the issues here, they do an exceptional job analyzing the core. I work in this industry and I have read quite a few articles and essays that discuss this issue and fail to grasp the fundamentals as well as this article does.

Leave a comment


Type the characters you see in the picture above.

This is to help prevent spamming and confirm you are a human

 

Sport blogs

Tony Jeffries

Glove Affair - Olympic boxing medallist Tony Jeffries
Website
My postings | Tony Jeffries' RSS feed My feed | Twitter

Stephen Farrell

Stephen Farrell - The Faz with a fan's eye view of NUFC
My postings | Stephen Farrell's RSS feed My feed

Joel Neasham

Joel Neasham - on horse racing
My postings | Joel Neasham's RSS feed My feed

Mark Douglas

Mark Douglas - on the sporting matters of the day
My postings | Mark Douglas' RSS feed My feed | Twitter

Blog Authors

Paul Younger

Professor Paul Younger - on a Newcastle University project harnessing the city's geothermal energy
My postings | Professor Paul Younger's RSS feed My feed

Will in Whitehall

Will in Whitehall - The Journal's Political Editor on life at Westminster
My postings | Will in Whitehall's RSS feed My feed | Twitter

Nicola Weatherall

Nicola Weatherall - Education Reporter Nicola Weatherall is training for the London Marathon.
My postings | Nicola Weatherall's RSS feed My feed

Brenda Boyd

Brenda Boyd - the life and times of a morris dancer
My postings | Brenda Boyd's RSS feed My feed

Hannah Davies

Hannah Davies - on family matters
My postings | Hannah Davies' RSS feed My feed

Write Said Fred

Write Said Fred - A view of the world from three feet
My postings | Write Said Fred's RSS feed My feed

Adrian Pearson

Adrian Pearson - The Journal's Regional Affairs Correspondent with a look behind the scenes of North East politics
My postings | Adrian Pearson's RSS feed My feed | Twitter

Laura Fraine

Laura Fraine - on family life
My postings | Laura Fraine's RSS feed My feed

Mieka Smiles

Mieka Smiles - on married life and expecting her first child
My postings | Mieka Smiles's RSS feed My feed

Karen Overbury

Karen Overbury - our homemaker editor writes and answers questions about property
My postings | Karen Overbury's RSS feed My feed

Zainab Radhi

Zainab Radhi - on life after leaving Tyneside for Iraq
My postings | Zainab Radhi's RSS feed My feed

Liz Lamb

Liz Lamb - talks about fashion
My postings | Liz Lamb's RSS feed My feed | Twitter

Daisy Green

Daisy Green Magazine - The online ethical webzine
My postings | Daisy Green's RSS feed My feed | Twitter

Katharine Capocci

Plot of Bother - allotment gardening with Katharine Capocci
My postings | Katharine Capocci' RSS feed My feed

Keep up to date

Sponsored Links