http://blogs.journallive.co.uk/journalblogcentral/

Scotland "soft-soaped" says Labour MP

By William Green on Apr 16, 12 12:11 PM

Scotland is sharing in a £190m boost thanks to money allocated to England to help its economy.

George Osborne announced last autumn an extra £1bn for the regional growth fund, which ministers created to boost private sector jobs in parts of England hit by public sector cuts.

But it has now emerged the devolved administrations of Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland will share £190m of separate funding as a result of that decision.

It is all down to the Barnett Formula, used to adjust spending in other nations of the UK when money is allocated to England. Researchers at the House of Commons set out the details in a briefing paper prepared for MPs.

And it has sparked fresh calls for a review of the system, with English MPs and business chiefs claiming Scotland does not need the money - unlike the North East - because it already enjoyed major competitive advantages.

Blaydon MP Dave Anderson blasted the Government's economic strategy and backed a review of the Barnett Formula.

"They deliberately ran down the regional development agencies out of political spite, which had been successful in our area. The regional growth fund is almost worse than nothing," said the Labour MP.

"And then money is going north of the border when they don't need it. We desperately want it in this part of the world."

He added: "It is just more evidence of the incompetence of this Government and people are becoming more and more aware of just how incompetent they are."

Mary Glindon, MP for North Tyneside, claimed that the coalition was desperate to show its support for Scotland in a bid to win the upcoming independence referendum.

"Scotland is going to get soft-soaped by this Government. I fear that the North East is going to miss out," she said.

The Labour MP also attacked the Barnett formula, saying: "It is seen as unfair by so many people in this country."

Andrew Tebbutt, executive member for corporate resources on Northumberland County Council, said: "We really do struggle in relation to our neighbours over the border already because they get other benefits.

"We just don't get as generous a deal in relation to Barnett [formula] as our Scottish neighbours."

The senior Liberal Democrat added: "At least let us compete on a level playing field."

North East Chamber of Commerce director of policy Ross Smith said: "It is difficult to understand why the Barnett Formula is still in place as its many inconsistencies have been repeatedly highlighted for well over a decade.

"This latest anomaly in the way the formula is applied only serves to highlight further that this system must be changed if the Government truly intends to rebalance the economy."

2 Comments

David Kelly said:

A Labour MP criticising the Barnett Formula? I don't remember too many of them doing that during their 13 years in Government. When Ms Glindon said, "[The Barnett Formula] is seen as unfair by so many people in this country," did she mean England or the entire 'Union' by the phrase 'this country'? She should make herself as clear as possible. England is a nation, not a bunch of phoney regions that the people of England have not been allowed to vote on, and don't want anyway.

By the way, Ms Glindon, it isn't just your neck of the woods that's suffering. It's all of England other than London and the Home Counties, which will always do well as long as there are politicians in Westminster, civil servants in Whitehall, and the hub of Britain's media. You don't think those people care about the rest of England, let alone our neighbouring countries, do you?

Danny Anderson said:

There is only one partty against the Barnett formula and wants to see the end of it guess who that might be ????????

THE SNP

Sport blogs

Tony Jeffries

Glove Affair - Olympic boxing medallist Tony Jeffries
Website
My postings | Tony Jeffries' RSS feed My feed | Twitter

Stephen Farrell

Stephen Farrell - The Faz with a fan's eye view of NUFC
My postings | Stephen Farrell's RSS feed My feed

Joel Neasham

Joel Neasham - on horse racing
My postings | Joel Neasham's RSS feed My feed

Mark Douglas

Mark Douglas - on the sporting matters of the day
My postings | Mark Douglas' RSS feed My feed | Twitter

Blog Authors

Paul Younger

Professor Paul Younger - on a Newcastle University project harnessing the city's geothermal energy
My postings | Professor Paul Younger's RSS feed My feed

Will in Whitehall

Will in Whitehall - The Journal's Political Editor on life at Westminster
My postings | Will in Whitehall's RSS feed My feed | Twitter

Nicola Weatherall

Nicola Weatherall - Education Reporter Nicola Weatherall is training for the London Marathon.
My postings | Nicola Weatherall's RSS feed My feed

Brenda Boyd

Brenda Boyd - the life and times of a morris dancer
My postings | Brenda Boyd's RSS feed My feed

Hannah Davies

Hannah Davies - on family matters
My postings | Hannah Davies' RSS feed My feed

Write Said Fred

Write Said Fred - A view of the world from three feet
My postings | Write Said Fred's RSS feed My feed

Adrian Pearson

Adrian Pearson - The Journal's Regional Affairs Correspondent with a look behind the scenes of North East politics
My postings | Adrian Pearson's RSS feed My feed | Twitter

Laura Fraine

Laura Fraine - on family life
My postings | Laura Fraine's RSS feed My feed

Mieka Smiles

Mieka Smiles - on married life and expecting her first child
My postings | Mieka Smiles's RSS feed My feed

Karen Overbury

Karen Overbury - our homemaker editor writes and answers questions about property
My postings | Karen Overbury's RSS feed My feed

Zainab Radhi

Zainab Radhi - on life after leaving Tyneside for Iraq
My postings | Zainab Radhi's RSS feed My feed

Liz Lamb

Liz Lamb - talks about fashion
My postings | Liz Lamb's RSS feed My feed | Twitter

Daisy Green

Daisy Green Magazine - The online ethical webzine
My postings | Daisy Green's RSS feed My feed | Twitter

Katharine Capocci

Plot of Bother - allotment gardening with Katharine Capocci
My postings | Katharine Capocci' RSS feed My feed

Keep up to date

Sponsored Links