http://blogs.journallive.co.uk/journalculturecentral/

Yes, it's quite funny, but it's not a joke

By Paul Loraine on Oct 31, 08 12:27 PM

I have a confession to make. I'm 24 and I listen to jazz. I'm continually told it's an embarrassing deformity of musical taste, that jazz fans are the hairy-backed males of the music community - everyone else pretends it's ok but really it's not.

My passion was greeted with predictable amusement in The Journal office.

Soon my colleagues had invented a back-story - I was a jazz oboe player who wanted to follow in the fictional path of the many imagined jazz-oboists who had blown sweet meoldies in the wilds of Northumberland before me.

It was unimportant to them that I am, in fact, a pianist. Truth was unimportant in these exchanges, they said. The oboe, I was told time and again, is a "much funnier instrument" and suited their purpose better.

Of course those witty friends of mine were not setting a trend. Jazz has always been a fruitful subject for comedians.

The Fast Show, and The Mighty Boosh are testament to that fact. It's not even as if they are imagining jazz to be funnier than it actually is.

Take Keith Jarrett, quite simply one of the best jazz musicians there has ever been. But no matter how beautiful his solo, no matter how absorbed the listener is in his playing, there remains something undeniably funny about a man with a strong resemblance to a weasel gyrating at the piano, letting out bursts of air between phrases as if he were being deflated.

It irritates me when people try and set up an 'us-and-them' opposition where jazz lovers take themselves far too seriously and it takes someone from the world of less-fringy music to point out all that is amusing about the jazz world.

I am perfectly aware of the silliness inherent in jazz thank you very much, and I've grown to accept it like an unfortunate moustache on the face of an otherwise beautiful woman.

Older/Newer

0 TrackBacks

Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: Yes, it's quite funny, but it's not a joke.

TrackBack URL for this entry: http://blogs.journallive.co.uk/cgi-bin/mt421/mt-tb.cgi/91896

3 Comments

Terry "the G-Man" Wallace said:

mate, to be fair, you are quite hairy. I'm not dissin' you or nuffin, 'coz all the best lads are. I'm just sayin'...

Howard said:

Good for you, Paul. Speaking as someone who can barely remember 34, let alone 24, it's nice to hear a fresh perspective.

Howard said:

Good for you, Paul. Speaking as someone who can barely remember 34, let alone 24, it's nice to hear a fresh perspective.

Blog Authors

GP

Culture Reviews - The Journal's reviews - and yours
Postings | Reviews RSS feed Feed

Culture Team

Wonfor and Wilson's Edinburgh Fringe - Sam and Karen take in as much as they can handle north of the border and report back
Our postings | Culture Team's RSS feed Our feed

Sam Wonfor

Wonfor's Watching - Sam Wonfor on the box
My postings | Sam Wonfor's RSS feed My feed

GP

GP's Song of the Day - what the Ginger Prince is listening to
My postings | Graeme Whitfield's RSS feed My feed

Matt McKenzie

Matt's Musical Melting Pot - Matt McKenzie's musical musings
My postings | Matt McKenzie's RSS feed My feed

GP

New Writing North Reading Room - submit your review to our monthly discussion group
My postings | Book Club's RSS feed My feed
Our website

New Writing North

New Writing North - Director Claire Malcolm on all things literary
Postings | New Writing North RSS feed Feed

Laura Sandy

Laura Sandy - on film
My postings | Laura Sandy's RSS feed My feed

Carolyn Jess-Cooke

Carolyn Jess-Cooke - Poet, novelist and university lecturer
My postings | Carolyn Jess-Cooke's RSS feed My feed

Keep up to date

Sponsored Links